This retrospective analysis of three qualitative studies, comprising 23 walking interviews, brings methodological self-criticism to the foreground. The investigations concern young women’s experiences of insecurity, older people’s negotiation of urban surroundings and constructions of masculinity. Five processes organise the comparison: production of the route, rhythm and pauses, body and co-presence, materiality of the environment, and the relation between discourse and practice. The decisive finding is that walking produces knowledge through negotiated exposure to places and unequal capacities to guide the encounter. A missing bench, an avoided street or a change of pace can become an epistemic event rather than incidental context. At the same time, the article refuses to celebrate mobility as inherently emancipatory: physical accessibility, ethical exposure and the possible instrumentalisation of vulnerability remain unresolved constraints. Its contribution joins critical social psychology, situated knowledge and urban fieldwork. It establishes that the participant’s route and the researcher’s position are constitutive features of the resulting data, not external sources of contamination.