Saturday, November 21, 2026

Lund, D.H. (2018) ‘Co-creation in urban governance: From inclusion to innovation’, Scandinavian Journal of Public Administration, 22(2), pp. 3–17.


The invitation to co-create may redistribute work without redistributing the authority to define a problem. Lund reconstructs a significant normative displacement in urban governance: participatory traditions centred on rights, empowerment and influence over decisions increasingly coexist with co-creation programmes assessed by innovation and problem-solving capacity. Her critical operation is to separate three citizen positions—co-implementer, co-designer and co-initiator—and examine what each demands in time, competence, initiative and access to institutions. These roles can expand opportunities for civic action, but no role guarantees inclusion of marginalised residents. The corresponding administrative positions—steward, mediator and catalyst—also require public officials to relinquish parts of their expert control. Lund distinguishes input legitimacy, concerned with who can influence the process, from output legitimacy, concerned with what it delivers. Her argument is conceptual and interpretive, not an empirical proof that co-creation necessarily depoliticises planning. Its precise warning is that innovation can become a substitute criterion for democratic authority, leaving unspecified whose problems receive attention. This distinction bridges urban planning, democratic theory, public administration and design research, while sharpening Socioplastics' need to document the route from participation to consequential decision-making.