A transdisciplinary project cannot be evaluated adequately as a conventional disciplinary study supplemented by outreach. Belcher and Claus reconstruct a quality-assessment framework whose criteria emerge from a systematic engagement with evaluation literature, followed by testing and revision. The framework organises research quality through four principles, associated criteria and a four-point scoring system; accompanying templates permit structured comparison and graphical examination of strengths and weaknesses. Its deeper methodological operation is to shift judgement upstream. Quality is not only something established after publications appear but a property of how a problem is positioned, how knowledge claims are made credible, how participation is constituted and how findings are prepared for use. Importantly, the authors distinguish positioning for use from proof that social change has already occurred. The distinction protects research from retrospective success narratives while demanding more rigorous accounts of potential uptake. For a geographically distributed collaboration, the framework can audit design choices without conflating territorial consistency with identical practice. It also raises a political question: whose criteria determine whether integration is sufficiently legitimate, usable and robust?