Saturday, November 7, 2026

Kilis, E., Adamsone-Fiskovica, A., Stræte, E.P., Värnik, R. and Kriipsalu, M. (2025) ‘The curious ambivalence of working with boundary objects: Interdisciplinarity, circularity, and processual alignment of perspectives’, Journal of Environmental Studies and Sciences, 16, pp. 110–123. https://doi.org/10.1007/s13412-025-01023-6


A shared term may coordinate work while concealing the persistence of incompatible research worlds. Drawing on literature review and retrospective autoethnographic observation of an international project on circular bioresource flows, Kilis and colleagues examine the practical career of boundary objects. Their critical finding is that common concepts can support pragmatic collaboration yet encourage black-boxing and disciplinary segregation when they are detached from sustained social interaction and concrete data-gathering situations. The paper therefore interrupts the comforting assumption that an agreed vocabulary constitutes epistemic integration. An object becomes productive through a processual alignment of perspectives, not merely because it is repeated in presentations, deliverables and meeting minutes. This observation bridges science and technology studies, rural and environmental research, and organisational accounts of project-based interdisciplinarity. For a walking protocol or digital interface, it supplies a demanding diagnostic test: does the device redistribute attention, expose incompatible judgements and alter practices, or does it simply provide a neutral-looking screen behind which separate teams continue independently? The danger of consensus is not only disagreement suppressed, but difference rendered technically invisible.