Tuesday, November 17, 2026

The Selective Interface: Trust Cues, Canon Formation and Urban Knowledge Infrastructures (Schröder, Guenther, Meloni, Laux, Hoffmann, Park, Feagan, Villegas Núñez, Awashra) · LAPIEZA LAB · Anto Lloveras · Socioplastics · 2026



An environment becomes scientifically and publicly legible through operations that are neither reducible to perception nor innocent of their material supports. The instrument that calls one urban surface ‘green space’, the newspaper that makes one expert recognisable, the archive that preserves a disciplinary conversation, and the map that renders a neighbourhood’s risks visible do not merely reproduce pre-existing objects. They establish a resolution at which objects can be distinguished, compared and acted upon. This is not the assertion that representation creates every material condition it describes: pollution, heat, enclosure, illness and uneven access remain materially consequential whether or not an index registers them. It is the narrower and more demanding proposition that the route from condition to evidence passes through classifications, formats, temporal conventions, institutional authority and possible audiences. Park, Brown and Pearson reveal this at the level of green-space audits: the alleged simplicity of a variable conceals divergent instruments for recording quality and divergent assumptions about what might matter to wellbeing. The absence of a single measurement standard is not merely a nuisance to be resolved by technical harmonisation, since the divergences also expose different environmental theories embedded within the measure. A path, a bench, water, maintenance or an opportunity for social encounter may enter the audit, while fear, exclusion or seasonal use may remain difficult to compare. Hoffmann and colleagues make a corresponding displacement in environmental discussion: describing change at the level of individual conduct or systemic responsibility changes perceived efficacy and relational risk. Here the medium of comparison is not a geographic sensor but an account of where agency sits. 

An issue can become more discussable without any increase in the quantity of information presented. The two examples together expose an asymmetry between data accumulation and the construction of a viable public object. More measures may fail to stabilise a useful meaning; a change in framing may alter the likelihood of participation without adding another environmental observation. Scientific communication therefore cannot be assigned a late, secondary position after the production of valid facts. Schröder and Guenther show that digital messages present identifiable ‘trust cues’ about expertise, integrity, benevolence, transparency and dialogue, and that these cues are unevenly distributed across media and represented speakers. Their content analysis does not establish automatic audience effects, but it identifies the communicative materials from which credibility judgements may be assembled. There is a profound difference between preserving a scientist’s words, rendering the person discoverable, allowing the conditions of that statement to be reconstructed, and making an argument publicly contestable. A permanent identifier can assist the first three without guaranteeing the fourth. The authority of an item, moreover, is not located wholly in its link or author field; it is mediated by recognisable conventions, selection routines and the ability of later readers to distinguish original context from subsequent use. This temporal difficulty becomes political at the scale of a discipline. Meloni and colleagues reconstruct the linguistic and geographical asymmetries of science and technology studies through a large bibliographic dataset, testing the field’s commitment to situated knowledge against the infrastructures that produce a canon. Citation concentration and editorial location make visible an uneven ecology of recognition, but neither a low citation count nor absence from an indexed journal can be equated with intellectual irrelevance. The institutional capacity to count is not identical to the epistemic capacity to judge. Nor does the inverse automatically follow: recovering neglected objects cannot be advertised as conceptual renewal before one has shown what their reintroduction changes. A disciplinary canon is an architecture of recurrent attention, assembled over time, not a portrait of everything thought or said. Laux and colleagues sharpen the problem by identifying how innovations can offer an image of disruption while preserving older sociomaterial arrangements. Their ‘non-disruptive disruption’ warns against making the technical openness of a platform stand in for changes to interpretative or institutional power. A participatory dashboard may record more voices and leave the definition of categories untouched; an open repository may conserve documents while still organising retrieval around historically dominant vocabularies; a translation tool may enlarge access while erasing the conceptual resistance of terms that do not pass neatly across languages. The critical object, then, is the selective interface: the set of designed and historically accumulated operations that turns heterogeneous situations into publicly addressable knowledge, with gains in visibility inseparable from new possibilities of omission. Its politics does not reside in whether it is digital or analogue, institutional or community-led, but in whether selection, provenance, contradiction and the conditions of return can themselves be made examinable. The interface is not merely where information appears; it is where the possibility of a common problem is negotiated.

That negotiation is particularly legible when the unit of inquiry moves from a published article to a city and then returns to the archive of the disciplines that study cities. Feagan and colleagues approach coastal resilience through social-ecological-technological systems and the co-production of visual knowledge with residents and institutional actors. Their work challenges the assumption that a sufficiently comprehensive dashboard will disclose urban complexity by itself: what a city needs to know, who can pose that question and how the answer will be used are part of the knowledge system’s design. Villegas Núñez and Niehaves further complicate the data-generating city through volunteered sensing and the WIN methodology, seeking to bring informal practices and residents’ situated priorities into the definition of urban problems. Yet to move from contribution to agency demands more than collecting and displaying observations. The entries must remain interpretable with respect to who produced them, under what constraint, in which language and for what possible decision. Awashra and colleagues expose another vulnerable passage in this translation, where collective discussion becomes a computer-generated landscape image. Their ‘controlled imperfect’ images recognise that excessive visual finish can prematurely suppress contestation: an image may open a proposition while also seeming to certify that a future has already been agreed. The transfer from speech to prompt, from prompt to image, and from image to planning document is therefore a chain of editorial decisions and losses. The apparent convenience of a seamless interface makes this chain harder to inspect. Socioplastics can use the problem to clarify the organisation of its own documentary and spatial practice without claiming that artworks, interviews, research papers, field notes, images and scientific data have interchangeable authority. A corpus becomes an infrastructure of inquiry when objects retain distinct provenance and epistemic status while acquiring relations through which they can be located, tested, compared and reconsidered. Such a corpus must distinguish persistence from discoverability, discoverability from interpretability, and interpretability from responsible reuse. No property follows mechanically from the preceding one. Metadata can retain the conditions of an encounter, but it can also impose retrospectively a category that the encounter did not use. Geolocation can make a testimony mappable while hiding the uncertainty of the speaker’s spatial reference. The translation of an interview into searchable text gives later readers a new comparative instrument while reducing vocal inflection, pauses and non-verbal relations. A new series can reconnect objects separated by time and disciplinary vocabulary, but the relation must not be confused with evidence that those authors endorsed a shared theory. Such distinctions matter for the reconstruction of environmental psychology proposed in FieldEco. The programme’s existing documentary history, including the long trajectory of Psicología Ambiental Hoy, permits hypotheses about how different representations preserve and organise the field; it does not yet prove that a redesigned architecture improves comprehension, methodological validity or collective action. That difference should structure any future empirical programme. One possible comparative design would take the same bounded set of environmental arguments and prepare, with disclosed editorial decisions, several access configurations: conventional bibliographic order, thematic classification, and provenance-sensitive relational navigation. The study would separately examine retrieval, contextual understanding, ability to recognise disagreement and responsible reuse, without conflating any one outcome with general epistemic improvement. Another could compare the way different inventories of environmental research represent language, region, method and participant position, then determine whether introducing missing traditions changes substantive propositions rather than simply the demographic appearance of the list. These are research designs to be tested, not results available for citation. In urban fieldwork the same caution applies: a map of access to green space, a qualitative account of care and a participatory image of a landscape proposal register different kinds of evidence. Their juxtaposition can reveal a contradiction, but it cannot establish causal effects without suitable inferential work. The point of a relational architecture is to keep their differences available while permitting questions that any one format would suppress. This also changes the economics of visibility. A repository deposit or a DOI is useful as a persistence mechanism, but academic recognition depends on further systems of peer review, disciplinary categorisation, citation and institutional evaluation. The public value of an archive likewise depends on whether its contents can be interpreted by audiences with unequal time, language proficiency, technical access and authority. A selective interface becomes critically productive when it discloses what it excludes, preserves contested versions, supports reversible classification and makes its own editorial transformations traceable. Neither total transparency nor exhaustive inclusion is possible, and not every object should circulate without restriction; privacy, consent and contextual obligations can require forms of deliberate opacity. The work is to distinguish necessary limits from invisible losses and to make the consequences of each boundary available for scrutiny. The archive, the urban map and the communication platform can then be analysed within one comparative question: not how much reality each captures, but what operations each allows people to perform upon evidence and where those operations fail. Within Socioplastics, this tension condenses as Relational Agency.

Anto Lloveras works across architecture, urbanism, epistemology and spatial research. Through LAPIEZA-LAB , he examines documentary infrastructures, comparative fieldwork, archives and the ways representational systems organise relations between places, knowledge.

BIBLIOGRAPHY

Awashra, I., Thompson, A.W., Floress, K., Arbuckle, J.G., Church, S.P., Genskow, K., Prokopy, L.S., Rui, Y. and Tesdell, O. (2025) ‘Generative AI text-to-image for community participation in landscape planning’, Landscape and Urban Planning, 264, article 105464. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.landurbplan.2025.105464

Feagan, M., Muñoz-Erickson, T.A., Hobbins, R., Baja, K., Chester, M., Cook, E.M., Grimm, N., Grove, M., Iwaniec, D.M., Iyer, S., McPhearson, T., Méndez-Lázaro, P., Miller, C., Sauter, D., Solecki, W., Tomateo, C., Troxler, T. and Welty, C. (2025) ‘Co-producing new knowledge systems for resilient and just coastal cities: A social-ecological-technological systems framework for data visualization’, Cities, 156, article 105513. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cities.2024.105513

Hoffmann, T., Mlakar, Ž., Rauws, W. and Bolderdijk, J.W. (2025) ‘Personal actions or systemic solutions: How the focus of the conversation influences willingness to talk about environmental issues’, Journal of Environmental Psychology, 105, article 102590. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jenvp.2025.102590

Laux, H., Matthäus, S., Wieghorst, C. and Zeltner, P. (2026) ‘Techno-fixes: On the non-disruptive disruptions of cultured meat, social freezing and AI assistants’, Social Studies of Science, 56(3), pp. 378–402. https://doi.org/10.1177/03063127251395213

Meloni, M., Issaka, A., Cadman, S., Hegarty, B., Chiapperino, L. and Moll, T. (2026) ‘Troubling the canon: Language, geography, and the politics of STS publishing in five decades of journal publications’, Social Studies of Science, 56(2), pp. 171–205. https://doi.org/10.1177/03063127251386080

Park, H., Brown, C.D. and Pearson, A.L. (2024) ‘A systematic review of audit tools for evaluating the quality of green spaces in mental health research’, Health & Place, 86, article 103185. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.healthplace.2024.103185

Schröder, J.T. and Guenther, L. (2025) ‘Mediating trust in content about science: Assessing trust cues in digital media environments’, Public Understanding of Science, 34(8), pp. 1046–1065. https://doi.org/10.1177/09636625251337709

Villegas Núñez, D.M. and Niehaves, B. (2026) ‘Bridging digital divides: User-generated data and volunteered urban sensing for inclusive smart city governance’, Cities, 179, article 107387. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cities.2026.107387