Showing posts with label science communication. Show all posts
Showing posts with label science communication. Show all posts

Tuesday, November 17, 2026

The Selective Interface: Trust Cues, Canon Formation and Urban Knowledge Infrastructures (Schröder, Guenther, Meloni, Laux, Hoffmann, Park, Feagan, Villegas Núñez, Awashra) · LAPIEZA LAB · Anto Lloveras · Socioplastics · 2026



An environment becomes scientifically and publicly legible through operations that are neither reducible to perception nor innocent of their material supports. The instrument that calls one urban surface ‘green space’, the newspaper that makes one expert recognisable, the archive that preserves a disciplinary conversation, and the map that renders a neighbourhood’s risks visible do not merely reproduce pre-existing objects. They establish a resolution at which objects can be distinguished, compared and acted upon. This is not the assertion that representation creates every material condition it describes: pollution, heat, enclosure, illness and uneven access remain materially consequential whether or not an index registers them. It is the narrower and more demanding proposition that the route from condition to evidence passes through classifications, formats, temporal conventions, institutional authority and possible audiences. Park, Brown and Pearson reveal this at the level of green-space audits: the alleged simplicity of a variable conceals divergent instruments for recording quality and divergent assumptions about what might matter to wellbeing. The absence of a single measurement standard is not merely a nuisance to be resolved by technical harmonisation, since the divergences also expose different environmental theories embedded within the measure. A path, a bench, water, maintenance or an opportunity for social encounter may enter the audit, while fear, exclusion or seasonal use may remain difficult to compare. Hoffmann and colleagues make a corresponding displacement in environmental discussion: describing change at the level of individual conduct or systemic responsibility changes perceived efficacy and relational risk. Here the medium of comparison is not a geographic sensor but an account of where agency sits. 

Wednesday, January 28, 2026

Rethinking scientific authority in climate discourse means shifting from absolute truths to plausible, collective justifications


Although climate science offers strong evidence for anthropogenic change, its effectiveness in public debates is often undermined by a misguided ideal: that science should be pure, neutral and infallible. This column critiques the cultural perception of science as a monolithic truth-telling machine, exposing how this vision fosters frustration when science enters the messy terrain of political and social contention. The scientific method, often depicted as a linear and infallible path to truth, is here reframed as a flexible and context-sensitive practice, reliant on collective interpretation and methodological pluralism. Drawing on Karen Kovaka's and Lee McIntyre's contributions, the text dismantles the notion of science as a producer of final truths, highlighting instead the plausibility of its claims as a more honest epistemic strategy. Through the lens of climate attribution studies—used to estimate the role of human activity in extreme weather events like the DANA flood—the column demonstrates how climate science operates not by pronouncing absolute certainties but by presenting highly justified, community-vetted assessments. A key example is the IPCC’s consensual diagnosis of climate change, which does not rely on metaphysical truths but on a wide convergence of data, models, and expert judgement. Therefore, rather than appealing to a "science that says," the author urges a humble, situated engagement with scientific knowledge, one that recognises its historical, social and value-laden dimensions. This approach not only fortifies public understanding but also disarms climate denialism, which thrives on attacking an idealised and unattainable version of science. In facing the ecological crisis, it is not certainty we must seek, but accountable, collaborative plausibility.